True freedom requires transcending capitalism, says Prabhat Patnaik

Prominent economist Prabhat Patnaik talking at a gathering in Vijayawada. | Photo Credit: HANDOUT

Capitalism can’t guarantee particular person freedom as a result of all brokers act below systemic compulsion. True freedom requires transcending capitalism, by making a system primarily based on collective possession and real cooperation, free from financial coercion and alienation, stated Marxian economist and political commentator Prabhat Patnaik.

Participating in a dialogue on “Beyond Liberalism”, his newest guide that provides a Marxist critique of liberalism in Vijayawada on Friday, the previous professor of Economics asserted that socialism, below which widespread possession of the technique of manufacturing is feasible, is thus the one framework the place actual particular person freedom can exist.

He stated given the present day’s disaster of neoliberal capitalism and suppression of freedom worldwide, the necessity for collective motion and socialist transformation was pressing. He stated his guide challenges two widespread liberal propositions — that liberalism values particular person freedom, whereas Marxism doesn’t, and that capitalism ensures particular person freedom, whereas socialism suppresses it.

“Both claims are false,” he argued, stating that Marxism is deeply involved with particular person freedom, and real freedom can solely be achieved below socialism, not capitalism.”

Mr. Patnaik, who taught on the Centre for Economic Studies and Planning within the School of Social Sciences at Jawaharlal Nehru University in New Delhi, spoke concerning the Marxist view of the Individual below capitalism. He stated people below capitalism don’t act freely; they’re pushed by systemic compulsion and competitors. He stated capitalism is dependent upon a “reserve military of labour” (the unemployed) to self-discipline employees by means of the “menace of job loss”. This creates ‘financial coercion’, as manufacturing requires strict coordination with out bodily pressure however below the worry of unemployment. “Hence, people, together with capitalists, are ‘alienated and unfree’, compelled to behave by market forces,” he stated.

Published – October 25, 2025 03:32 pm IST

  • Related Posts

    Lamborghini seized after Kanpur crash released after 8.5 crore bond payment

    The Lamborghini involved in the high-profile road accident in Kanpur earlier this month has reportedly been released after a bond of ₹8.5 crore was furnished. The accident, which left six…

    Rubio says no Russian oil again, Jaishankar stresses strategic autonomy, question remains over Trump’s tariff order

    Donald Trump’s administration continues to claim that India has committed to stop buying oil from Russia — in return for a tariff-cut and trade deal — with US Secretary of…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Vijay Sethupathys Muthu Alias Kaattaan gets release date; teaser unveiled

    Vijay Sethupathys Muthu Alias Kaattaan gets release date; teaser unveiled

    The Genius of Trees: Read an excerpt from the book by Harriet Rix

    The Genius of Trees: Read an excerpt from the book by Harriet Rix

    Lamborghini seized after Kanpur crash released after 8.5 crore bond payment

    Lamborghini seized after Kanpur crash released after  8.5 crore bond payment

    Prague Masters: Gukesh suffers shock defeat to van Foreest, Aravindh draws with Maghsoodloo

    Prague Masters: Gukesh suffers shock defeat to van Foreest, Aravindh draws with Maghsoodloo

    The Kerala Story 2 box office prediction: Controversy buzz doesn’t help sequel, film to open at less than half of part 1

    The Kerala Story 2 box office prediction: Controversy buzz doesn’t help sequel, film to open at less than half of part 1

    Subedaar: Full music album of Anil Kapoors upcoming actioner out

    Subedaar: Full music album of Anil Kapoors upcoming actioner out